He requests all passengers proceed directly to the main dining room where an officer will call the roll in 10 minutes and specialty coffees and pastries will be served.
Sinking of the MS Arctic Sun in Cumberland Sound, Nunavut
…a deep metallic groan resounds throughout the ship as it jerks and shudders violently.
THE INCIDENT
The sinking of the Arctic Sun takes place 31 kilometres from the hamlet of Pangnirtung, NU.
Pangnirtung is a picturesque community of just over 1,400 people, primarily of Inuit origin, situated on the south shore of Pangnirtung Fiord, off Cumberland Sound on Baffin Island, Nunavut. … Evidence of Inuit habitation of the Cumberland Sound region dates back millennia to the Thule and Dorset peoples, predecessors of the Inuit, indicating continuous occupation of these lands and waters since time immemorial.
On board are 114 passengers and 54 crew.
MS ARCTIC SUN
- Length
- 105 m (345 ft)
- Max Draft
- 4.7 m (15 ft)
- Lifeboats
- 4 x 50-man, 4 x 12-man
- Forward-looking sonar
- None
The Canadian Ice Service (CIS) reports indicate the north end and much of the west side of Cumberland Sound as far south as Kingnait Fiord are solidly blocked with pans of 3/10 to 8/10 ice, forcing the Arctic Sun to hug the eastern shoreline of the Sound as it makes its way past the Kikastan Islands.
Just as the ship makes its approach and rounds the head off Brown Harbour to enter the mouth of the fiord, the radar indicates an iceberg is positioned directly ahead in the ship’s path…
- Max Draft
- 4.7 m (15 ft)
- Forward-looking sonar
- None
With no ideal option available, the captain takes his decision and orders the bridge to alter course to the most easterly line of soundings. … This should allow the iceberg to pass at least 500 metres to the west of the ship, but places the vessel at the extreme edge of the charted waters.
Many on board have braved the inclement weather to photograph the impressive ice formation as it passes.
The captain and officers on the bridge quickly realize their ship has run aground. … Their position at the time of impact is 65.944606 N - 65.961609 W.
The Engineer has discovered fuel tank number six on the starboard side, carrying 87M3 of diesel, has been damaged. … Of greater concern, water is seeping into the adjacent mechanical room.
…the situation appears irreversible and the realization dawns that the ship is now at risk of foundering.
The captain returns to the bridge, contacts the Marine Communications and Traffic Services (MCTS) in Iqaluit to apprise them of the situation, and broadcasts a Mayday call to all ships in the vicinity.
MCTS has noted a strong tendency for captains to delay requests for assistance during groundings or other emergencies based on fear of the significant costs that would be incurred to ship owners … The result is that ships are often in serious danger before MCTS authorities are authorized to request assistance or a Mayday is issued.
The evacuation of the ship is completed. … The cook, 62, is experiencing chest pain.
The ship is listing 22 degrees to starboard and is partially submerged.
How will they be rescued?
“WHO IS IN CHARGE?”
All through the summer Inuit people are on Cumberland Sound…this is a highway in the summer … if it were to happen out there, somebody would see it.
There are approximately 150 boats owned by residents of the community, many of them larger commercial fishing vessels, and August would be the height of the fishing season.
THE NORTHERN PERSPECTIVE
It was also unanimously agreed that local people would respond to the crisis immediately regardless of formal mandates or training.
Pangnirtung
THE JRCC PERSPECTIVE
Air assets, equipment and SAR technicians would be launched from Canadian Forces Base Greenwood, N.S. within two hours of the call-out and could be expected to arrive on scene in Cumberland Sound anywhere from 13 to 27 hours later, depending on travel conditions.
Canadian Forces Base Greenwood, N.S.
Given this event occurs on a Saturday, the expectation would be that SAR crews would be assembled and “wheels up” within 2 hours of notification (departure times during weekday business hours are set at 30 minutes).
Unfortunately, when the responses were collated, the answers showed widely differing opinions as to who that critical individual and authority would be.
THE NORTHERN PERSPECTIVE
The main command post was identified as the hamlet office in Pangnirtung.
THE JRCC PERSPECTIVE
They identified the location of the command post as the JRCC headquarters in Halifax.
…and still others resolved the issue with a somewhat pragmatic “whoever gets there first.”
…the issue is who is in the best position to save lives – that’s who’s in charge! Not someone who is ten hours away under any kind of circumstances that I can imagine….
Several Pangnirtung residents recounted how, on that occasion, the offer of assistance from local residents who knew exactly where the injured individuals were located was refused by the JRCC SAR techs, who were confident in their own technology and ability to find the hikers. … Sometime later, the SAR techs had to return to the community to ask for help, having been unable to locate the injured parties.
Any requirement for local officials to fall under JRCC’s direction in co-ordinating the search was perceived by some in the community as “paternalistic” and a manifestation of a “colonial mentality.”
At the time of the interviews, JRCC were not familiar with Pangnirtung’s municipal Emergency Response Plan … were averse to the notion of a local official directing the response without the appropriate training and mandate.
It is only after we get the order from my Director in Hay River that I would respond to a distress call, regardless of whether that was a local fisherman in distress or a bigger boat that requires our assistance.
…the only three trained marine rescuers in the community would be answering to an outside authority while all other responders would be looking to the SAO for direction…
It was reported during interviews with territorial officials that the Hay River CGA leadership was on occasion, especially during the summer months, unreachable by telephone for days at a time.
MCTS follows a very precise program of call-outs, beginning with the appropriate JRCC, and including all key federal and territorial agencies or outside stakeholders who would play any role in the event of a major marine rescue or environmental disaster.
Responsibility for emergency management in the Arctic is a spread among a wide array of federal, territorial and municipal agencies supported by a patchwork of legislative authorities and mandates.
When asked who in the community MCTS would contact, MCTS identified the RCMP and the Hunters and Trappers Association (HTA) as the appropriate contacts. … This was the only occasion in this study where the Hunter and Trappers Association was identified as an official point of contact, and while this organization does play a significant role in many communities, it is not identified as a key responder in the communities’ new response plans.
Both admitted they had not had the opportunity to meet or work together prior to being presented with this scenario…
nobody can open those things
One of the more curious issues to emerge in the course of this study revolved around the oil spill remediation equipment that was delivered in locked sea-cans to select communities, including Pangnirtung, by the Environmental Response (ER) division of the Coast Guard.
…we now have it verified that it’s physically on the beach but we can’t get into it because it’s got a bizarre padlock on it that nobody can crack…
…none of these responder organizations, including members of the other branches of the Coast Guard, had any knowledge of where Environmental Response held the keys to this critical spill response equipment.
The majority of those interviewed speculated they might be stored at ER centers in Hay River, NWT, or at the Ontario ER centers in Sarnia or Prescott. … All these locations are thousands of miles away from the cached ER equipment.
At the time of writing and despite persistent efforts, the location of the keys to the Pangnirtung ER sea-can had not been confirmed by ER.
Why are the keys not here? … Those keys should be in Iqaluit or wherever they have equipment sitting.
…during a local marine rescue in one of the communities in Nunavut where ER equipment is cached … After much inter-jurisdictional discussion, permission was granted to local officials to break off the lock and access the ER boat. … When the necessary pieces were extracted, it was discovered that the shaft for the motor, a piece essential to its operation, was the wrong size.
If they (ER) had needed it, that outboard wouldn’t have worked
We’d probably at that point get bolt cutters and go and try and take a look.
…hamlet officials agreed they would have no hesitation in cutting the lock to the sea-can … they would act first and ask forgiveness later.
It is unlikely the Coast Guard would support local involvement in the containment of the spill, or condone the use of ER’s cached equipment by non-authorized individuals. … Community members would likely be ordered to stand down until trained ER personnel could arrive on scene or a CG icebreaker could reach the site.
Though it is entirely probable that the intervention of the people of Pangnirtung would have ensured the timely rescue of the Arctic Sun’s passengers and the containment of the spill, there remain indications of some significant gaps and anomalies that run counter to the principle tenets of sound emergency management theory and the Incident Command System.
EPILOGUE
On Oct. 9, 2013, the Munk-Gordon Arctic Security Program held a Roundtable on Emergency Preparedness in Iqaluit, Nunavut. … a representative from JRCC Halifax, albeit a different member than the officers interviewed for this exercise, and the SAO of Pangnirtung had an opportunity to meet face-to-face…
Not surprisingly, those discussions led to a better understanding of how they could collaborate constructively in emergency response in the future and forged the beginnings of a working relationship.
Are we ready for a cruise ship to sink near Pangnirtung today? The answer may be “not nearly ready enough.”
Only time will tell if the future will prove us so lucky.